Less Myth, More Measurement: Decomposing Excess Returns from the 1989 Minimum Wage Hike

IZA Logo

IZA Seminar

Place: Schaumburg-Lippe-Str. 9, 53113 Bonn

Date: 19.07.2011, 12:15 - 13:30


Presentation by 

Carl Lin (Bucknell University)


In the book of Myth and Measurement, Card and Krueger (1995) examine the economic impact of 1989 minimum wage hike on the welfare of 110 firms which employ a disproportionate number of minimum-wage workers. Their results show mixed evidence that excess returns associated with news about the 1989 minimum-wage legislation. This paper re-examines this question by decomposing excess returns. Our simple and intuitive approach attributes excess returns to either differences in market performances (economy-wide factor) or firm-specific traits (individualistic factor). Our results confirm Card and Krueger (1995), showing that generally the minimum wage legislation had little or no effect on employer wealth. However, by decomposing total excess returns, we find that the apparent lack of an effect is a consequence of two equivalent forces: (1) a negative effect arising from firm-specific traits (adverse information on minimum-wage worker employers) and (2) a positive effect arising from market performance. In other words, we show that while the aggregate effect of the 1989 minimum wage hike was neutral, there was a significant negative impact on firms that was neutralized by positive market performance.

Download complete paper   
For more information, please contact seminar@iza.org